Carmel Weighs Permanent Pickleball Ban as Coachella Valley Players Push Back

A debate over pickleball is heating up in Northern California, and it’s catching the attention of players across the Coachella Valley. The city of Carmel-by-the-Sea is now reviewing a proposal to permanently ban pickleball at all public courts following complaints from residents who say the sound is too disruptive.

Tiani Jadulang joined us live in studio after speaking with local players of all skill levels who say the concerns are understandable, but they believe the benefits of the sport far outweigh the noise. In almost every public park in the Central Coachella Valley, one or more pickleball courts can be found, a sign of the sport’s explosive growth nationwide.

The familiar pop of paddles and balls has become a signature sound, but it has also fueled frustration in some communities. During a recent Carmel City Council meeting, residents voiced concerns about the constant noise, prompting the council to explore a permanent ban.

Hundreds of miles away, local pickleball players have been following the developments closely. Many say banning the sport entirely would be a mistake. One longtime member of the Valley Scorpions pickleball group noted that players of all ages, especially older adults, rely on the sport for physical activity, mental sharpness, and community connection. He added that pickleball has become so popular in the Coachella Valley that tennis courts are being converted to meet demand, and some homebuyers even prioritize communities with strong pickleball programs.

Players also point out that noise concerns can be addressed without eliminating the sport. Options include quieter paddles, foam practice balls, and design adjustments to reduce sound levels. While the playing experience changes slightly, they say it represents a practical compromise.

Noise complaints have even influenced local decisions, including a delay in Palm Springs on a proposed 16-court pickleball complex. As Carmel continues debating a permanent ban, players in the Coachella Valley say the sport’s widespread benefits should not be overlooked.

Live in studio, Tiani Jadulang, NBC Palm Springs.

Explore: NBCPalmSprings.com, where we are connecting the Valley.