New Federal Judicial Ethics Guidance Says Judges May Respond to ‘Illegitimate’ Attacks

Newly released ethics guidance for the federal judiciary clarifies that judges may publicly respond to what it calls “illegitimate forms of criticism and attacks,” while still emphasizing the need for restraint to maintain public trust in the courts.

The updated guidance affirms that judges can take part in civic engagement, including speaking and writing about core issues such as the rule of law and judicial independence. However, it stresses that judges must exercise caution when sharing personal views to protect the integrity of the judiciary and maintain public confidence.

The advisory comes amid growing concern over threats, harassment, and public criticism directed at members of the judiciary. Federal judges have increasingly spoken about violence and intimidation targeting them, their families, and court staff. Past incidents, including the fatal 2020 shooting of a federal judge’s son, have heightened security concerns across the court system.

The new opinion also references recent commentary from Chief Justice John Roberts, who has warned that violence, intimidation, disinformation, and calls to defy court orders undermine judicial independence. He has previously stated that impeachment is not an appropriate response to disagreements over judicial decisions.

Ethics officials say the updated language reflects long-standing principles but clarifies that judges may, in some situations, offer measured responses to criticism that threatens the rule of law or judicial independence.

The guidance also notes that judges should consider tone, context, and form when speaking publicly, including situations where remarks may not be intended for public attribution.

Legal observers say the update provides clearer boundaries for judges navigating an increasingly contentious public environment, reinforcing that they can defend the judiciary while remaining mindful of their role.

Explore: NBCPalmSprings.com, where we are connecting the Valley.