Debate Grows Over Airport Shoe Removal Policy as Lawmaker Pushes for Return

A debate is growing over airport security procedures as a push emerges to bring back a familiar rule for travelers — removing shoes at TSA checkpoints.

Illinois Senator Tammy Duckworth is calling on the Department of Homeland Security to reinstate the “shoes off” policy, arguing that the current system may pose a security risk.

Passengers have been allowed to keep their shoes on since a policy change last July, a move aimed at speeding up security lines and improving the travel experience.

Former Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem defended the change at the time, saying efforts should focus on maintaining safety while making the process more efficient for travelers.

But now, Duckworth says new findings from the DHS Inspector General raise concerns. According to her office, some full-body scanners are not able to properly screen shoes, potentially creating a vulnerability in airport security.

Travelers appear divided on the issue. Some say bringing back shoe removal would slow down already long lines, while others believe any added security measure is worth the inconvenience.

Experts say the policy dates back more than two decades, following the attempted “shoe bomber” attack, and note that TSA procedures have often evolved in response to specific threats.

Aviation security researcher Sheldon Jacobson says the key question now is whether current screening methods are sufficient for the average traveler, especially those not enrolled in TSA PreCheck, who have traditionally been allowed to keep their shoes on.

The Department of Homeland Security has pointed to advancements in technology and a layered security approach as justification for the current policy, though officials have not provided detailed updates on those improvements.

For now, no changes have been announced, but the renewed discussion could impact how millions of travelers move through airport security in the future.

Explore: NBCPalmSprings.com, where we are connecting the Valley.