Supreme Court Rejects President Trump's Appeal to Overturn E. Jean Carroll Verdict

The United States Supreme Court on Monday rejected a legal effort by President Donald Trump to overturn a civil jury verdict in his long-running dispute with writer E. Jean Carroll. By refusing to grant a review of the case, the nine justices left intact a 2023 trial outcome and a corresponding five million dollar civil judgment against Trump, effectively exhausting his final avenue of appeal for this specific verdict.

The legal battle stems from a civil trial where a Manhattan federal jury concluded that Trump had sexually abused Carroll inside a luxury department store dressing room in 1996, and subsequently defamed her when he publicly denied the encounter. Carroll first brought her allegations forward in a 2019 memoir and later initiated the lawsuit in 2022 under New York's Adult Survivors Act. The temporary state law opened a one-year window allowing survivors of historical sexual misconduct to pursue civil claims that would otherwise have been blocked by the statute of limitations.

President Trump has consistently maintained his innocence and denied the allegations throughout the proceedings. In seeking the high court's intervention, Trump's defense attorneys argued that the trial judge broke federal evidentiary rules by permitting highly inflammatory testimonies from two other historical accusers, alongside the introduction of the infamous 2005 Access Hollywood audio recording. His legal team insisted that these pieces of evidence unfairly prejudiced the jury, while Carroll's attorneys urged the Supreme Court to reject the petition, arguing that the trial court's decisions were entirely consistent with established legal precedent.

Monday's Supreme Court order applies exclusively to the five million dollar award from the initial trial. Separately, a second federal jury awarded Carroll an additional 83.3 million dollars in damages after finding that Trump continued to defame the columnist through public statements made during and after his first presidential term. Trump's legal team is also actively appealing that massive second judgment through the lower appellate courts, though that case has not yet reached the Supreme Court for consideration.

Explore NBCPalmSprings.com, where we are connecting the valley.