CA, US & World

Supreme Court Hand Faith-Based Pregnancy Centers Unanimous Win in First Amendment Subpoena Fight

Supreme Court Hand Faith-Based Pregnancy Centers Unanimous Win in First Amendment Subpoena Fight

The US Supreme Court on Wednesday allowed a group of faith-based “crisis pregnancy centers” in New Jersey to fight a subpoena from the state’s Democratic attorney general. The decision may make it easier for both liberal and conservative groups to challenge similar investigatory subpoenas in the future.

At a time when states are pursuing radically different policies on abortion, immigration, and LGBTQ rights, the religious nonprofit First Choice Women’s Resource Centers argued that their inability to make their case in federal court was a threat to any group that could be targeted by state officials.

Justice Neil Gorsuch wrote the unanimous opinion for the court. “Since the 1950s, this court has confronted one official demand after another like the Attorney General’s,” Gorsuch wrote. “Over and again, we have held those demands burden the exercise of First Amendment rights. The Attorney General has offered a variety of arguments... none succeeds.”

The nonprofit First Choice runs five centers in New Jersey designed to advise women against having an abortion. New Jersey Attorney General Matthew Platkin subpoenaed the centers in 2023 as part of an investigation into whether the group violated consumer fraud laws, suggesting their marketing misled patients into thinking they provided abortion services.

The state sought advertisements, donor information, and the identities of medical personnel. The subpoena was issued more than a year after the Supreme Court’s 2022 decision to overturn Roe v. Wade. While the case had ties to the abortion debate, it centered on the power of state officials to investigate versus the power of federal courts to intervene.

The court leaned on a 1958 landmark decision involving the NAACP, which ruled that compelled disclosure of membership lists violates the right to association because people would reasonably fear retaliation for being named.

Click here for Dobbs decision background

Click here for California charitable contributions precedent

Explore NBCPalmSprings.com, where we are connecting the valley.

By: CNN Newsource

April 29, 2026

Supreme Court crisis pregnancy centersFirst Choice Womens Resource Centers v PlatkinNeil Gorsuch First AmendmentNew Jersey abortion subpoenadonor privacy SCOTUS 2026NBC Palm Springs
Link Copied To Clipboard!
Latest Instagram Posts
11

Gas prices in Riverside County are climbing toward $6 a gallon — and that’s more than $1 higher than this time last year. A 15-gallon fill-up now costs about $86, leaving many drivers wondering how much longer they can absorb the rising cost. On this week’s Roggin Report, Fred Roggin and the panel debate how expensive gas is changing the way people travel, work and live — and why prices are so much higher here. Watch the full conversation at NBCPalmSprings.com. #RogginReport #FredRoggin #GasPrices #RiversideCounty #CoachellaValley

51

As the Lindsay Clancy trial begins to close, discussions regarding postpartum mental health and postpartum care have began to draw attention to the level of care needed after childbirth. Maria Noble Valdez looked at this discussion locally with a mental health expert and mom here in Coachella Valley. #lindsayclancytrial #pospartum #mentalhealth #760 #nationalnews

51

EVEN PARKING HAS A VIP SECTION? A mall in Bakersfield is charging shoppers up to $10 a day for preferred parking spots closer to the entrance. So we had to ask: Would you pay for a better parking spot? And could paid parking eventually come to Valley malls? Fred Roggin and the panel weigh in on this week’s Roggin Report. Would you pay $10 for a prime parking spot? #RogginReport #FredRoggin #CoachellaValley #PalmSprings #Parking

7

📞 Call 760.466.0800 or visit DAPHealth.org to schedule your appointment today! Flu viruses change every year, and getting vaccinated is the best way to strengthen your immune system, lower the risk of severe illness or hospitalization, and protect your loved ones. Sponsored by: DAP Health

363

A wedding day they’ll never forget. 💍🌊 A couple in the Philippines refused to let monsoon flooding wash away their special day — exchanging vows while standing waist-deep in floodwaters. Talk about making a splash on your wedding day! #WeddingDay #Philippines #Flooding #Monsoon #Wedding #Love #NBCPalmSprings

132

Idyllwild’s Mayor Max III is turning four! Yes, you read that right — Idyllwild has a canine mayor, and Mayor Maximus Mighty-Dog Mueller III is celebrating his fourth birthday this week. Max is part of a tradition that began in 2012, when the mountain community first elected a dog as mayor. His “campaign donations”? Belly rubs and dog treats. Mayor Max’s birthday celebration is happening Saturday, September 5, at Mountain Paws in Idyllwild, and the community is invited. Come celebrate the mayor — and maybe bring a treat. #NBCPalmSprings #Idyllwild #MayorMax #MayorMaxIII #PalmSprings CoachellaValley DogsOfInstagram DogMayor CaliforniaNews

27

☕️ Social Time with Thalia & Jerry

156

More than 2,000 rescues — and the year isn’t over yet. Santa Clemente lifeguards are keeping a close eye on the Pacific as they prepare for potentially stronger surf and bigger waves this winter. From Tower Zero, lifeguards monitor the entire beach and use cameras to spot trouble in the water. One of their biggest concerns? Rip currents, which can pull swimmers far from shore. With more rescues already this year than all of last year, lifeguards say the key is simple: be ready before someone needs help. #SanClemente #Lifeguards #OceanSafety #RipCurrents #BeachSafety SurfSafety SouthernCalifornia PacificOcean NBCPalmSprings

347

The Salton Sea is at a crossroads. From a massive restoration project bringing habitat back to the shoreline, to a potential lithium boom, and the new Salton Sea Conservancy, its future is being shaped right now. We’re taking you behind the scenes to explore what comes next for the Salton Sea. In our newest 30-minute report, go behind-the-scenes with the state’s conservation team, learn about updated timlines from lithium executives, and hear how former political leaders paved the way. Restoring the Salton Sea: Progress, Promise and Pressure. Streaming this Sunday on NBC Palm Springs. #saltonsea #lithiumvalley #saltonseaconservancy #marybono

332

A few PSUSD students will get a unique opportunity to learn more about careers in Aviation at the Palm Springs Air Museum with the districts launch of their Aviation and Aeronautics Career Exploration Program. Be sure to stay tuned with NBC Palm Springs to learn all about this. #palmspringsairmuseum #palmsprings #aviationeducation #psusd #backtoschool

Supreme Court Hand Faith-Based Pregnancy Centers Unanimous Win in First Amendment Subpoena Fight