Earlier this year, California became the first state to offer free health care to undocumented immigrants. But with a mounting budget deficit, that policy is changing. The state now plans to charge undocumented recipients $100 per month starting next year.
The shift has sparked widespread debate—especially in the East Valley, where many undocumented immigrants live and work. NBC Palm Springs contributors Anthony Turk and Nick Collins weighed in on the issue this week.
“If they’re paying taxes—and a lot of them are—there should be a way for them to buy into our health care system because we need them,” said Turk.
Collins pushed back: “They’re not buying in. They’re getting it for free. And now California is facing a deficit. Programs like this are a big reason why.”
Governor Gavin Newsom is expected to soon announce details of California’s budget shortfall, despite the state being home to the fourth largest economy in the world.
The conversation sparked the most community response of any topic covered this week. On Facebook, viewer opinions were split.
Kirsten wrote: “So undocumented people get California health care for $100, but our vets can’t even get a place to live. Thanks, California, for helping our own people.”
Bruce added: “Is he really serious? How many people in the state need insurance and he is giving it away? Wake up, folks.”
Neffy commented: “I pay $1,000 a month for just my wife and I. How is it fair that immigrants practically get free health care that my taxes pay for?”
Not all feedback was critical. Ruby posted: “NBC Palm Springs, excuse me, you’re going to use your platform to debate? Health care is a human right.”
Jackie shared: “It beats giving it away with definitely a slippery slope. Being here illegally is a misdemeanor. Reentry after deportation is a felony.”
As of January 1, 2026, undocumented immigrants will no longer be eligible to enroll in California’s Medi-Cal expansion program.
Explore: NBCPalmSprings.com, where we are connecting the Valley.
By: Fred Roggin
May 16, 2025
