For years, dog owners have believed their pets can sense good or bad vibes in people. But new research is shaking that belief, suggesting dogs may not actually judge human character the way we think.

The study, which observed 40 dogs, indicates that dogs are more likely responding to human behaviors and cues rather than making moral judgments. In other words, they’re reacting to how we act and what we offer, not who we are as people.

Doug Baker, a lifelong dog owner, admitted that the findings surprised him. “I used to think that until I read that study today. Apparently, they can’t tell if someone is generous or stingy. They’re just happy to be with whoever they’re with, which breaks my heart because we love these dogs so much. And apparently, they don’t care.”

Jamie Baker wasn’t convinced. “They only studied 40 dogs. How would they get any facts out of that? Dogs don’t judge; they just want food. If I give them kibbles and someone else has chicken, they’ll go to the chicken. And if I’ve got sausage, they’ll come back to me.”

Doug admitted it was tough to accept. “It breaks my heart to think they don’t care if they’re with me, Jamie, or someone else. I want them to care.”

Jamie believes there’s more to it than food. “Our dog Mochi is almost 12 and a half. If I cry or get upset, she’s right next to me. I know she understands. That’s not just food; that’s connection.”

Still, Doug pointed out that their dogs switch loyalties depending on who is home. “When Jamie’s gone, Mochi is with me all day. When she comes back, she’s right back to Jamie. Same with Doobie. Why? She feeds them.”

While the debate continues in living rooms everywhere, one thing remains certain: whether driven by instinct, comfort, or snacks, dogs know exactly where they want to be.

Explore: NBCPalmSprings.com, where we are connecting the Valley.

New Study Challenges Idea That Dogs Judge Human Character